Home TV News ‘Doctor Who’ Producer Shortlist: 4 Reported Contenders and What Each Could Bring to the TARDIS

‘Doctor Who’ Producer Shortlist: 4 Reported Contenders and What Each Could Bring to the TARDIS

by Dave Elliott

The BBC’s search for the next team to take charge of ‘Doctor Who‘ has moved into its next phase, with a reported shortlist of production companies now competing to take the keys to the TARDIS. And while we still don’t know who will be running the show, or indeed who will be playing the Doctor, we are getting a clearer picture of the companies hoping to regenerate the long-running sci-fi series.

According to Deadline, around half a dozen UK production companies have made it through the initial selection process, with four contenders now identified, although one remains unnamed within the BBC Studios group.

As we covered when the original bids emerged in October, there are some familiar names, some interesting possibilities, and one proposal which could involve packing up the TARDIS and moving it north of the border.

So, who is actually in the running, what have they made before, and what could each bring to the next era of ‘Doctor Who’?

1. Hat Trick Mercurio: Jed Mercurio’s Bid

Known for: ‘Trigger Point’, ‘Bloodlands’, ‘DI Ray’

Perhaps the most high-profile bid comes from Hat Trick Mercurio (HTM), the production company established by ‘Line of Duty’ creator Jed Mercurio and Hat Trick founder Jimmy Mulville.

Mercurio is attached to the proposed ‘Doctor Who’ production as an executive producer. Beyond the shows produced by HTM, his writing credits include ‘Line of Duty’, ‘Bodyguard’, and the 1998 science-fiction drama ‘Invasion: Earth’. So, while he is best known for police and political thrillers, science fiction isn’t entirely unfamiliar territory.

The strengths: Mercurio is exceptionally good at constructing tension, mysteries and stories that keep audiences talking. His shows frequently become major television events, and that ability to build anticipation could be enormously valuable to ‘Doctor Who’.

There is also the combination of Mercurio’s creative experience and Mulville’s substantial production background, giving the bid considerable industry weight.

The concerns: As I mentioned in our previous coverage, I love much of Mercurio’s work, but the resolution of the H mystery in ‘Line of Duty’ still leaves me a little nervous about handing him a franchise with more than sixty years of mythology.

There is also a difference between making a gripping adult thriller and delivering the mixture of adventure, humour, scares and family entertainment that ‘Doctor Who’ needs.

Crucially, Mercurio is attached as an executive producer, not necessarily as head writer or showrunner. We still don’t know how directly involved he would be in shaping the scripts.

2. World Productions: ITV Studios’ Contender

Known for: ‘Line of Duty’, ‘Bodyguard’, ‘Vigil’, ‘Karen Pirie’, ‘Showtrial’

World Productions, which has been owned by ITV Studios since 2017, is another major contender.

And yes, that means the company behind ‘Line of Duty’ is competing separately against its creator, Jed Mercurio. It’s a slightly unusual situation, but both companies have their own production operations and are putting forward distinct bids.

World has an impressive track record producing major British dramas. Alongside its police thrillers, its catalogue includes the cult 1998 vampire series ‘Ultraviolet’, showing that genre television isn’t completely outside its experience.

There is another interesting connection here. Producer Marcus Wilson, who worked on ‘Karen Pirie’, previously produced ‘Doctor Who’, including its 50th anniversary era. There is no indication that he is attached to World’s bid, but it does demonstrate that the company has worked with people who understand the particular demands of the series.

The strengths: World has experience delivering ambitious, high-profile dramas for major broadcasters, including the BBC. It knows how to manage returning series, large casts and complex productions.

Its ownership by ITV Studios also gives it the backing of one of Britain’s biggest television production groups.

The concerns: Much like Hat Trick Mercurio, World’s strongest recent credentials are in adult drama rather than family science-fiction adventure.

There is also the practical question of capacity, with the company heading into another busy period that includes the highly anticipated seventh series of ‘Line of Duty’.

Still, the thought of an ITV-owned company taking charge of one of the BBC’s most recognisable programmes is rather entertaining. Although, given World already produces plenty of BBC drama, it wouldn’t be quite the broadcasting scandal it might sound like.

3. STV Studios: The Scottish Proposal

Known for: ‘Blue Lights’, ‘Criminal Record’, ‘Elizabeth Is Missing’, ‘Screw’

The most geographically interesting contender is STV Studios, Scotland’s largest television production group.

Its drama operations include Two Cities Television, which produces ‘Blue Lights’, Tod Productions, behind the Apple TV thriller ‘Criminal Record’, and Blackhill, whose credits include ‘Elizabeth Is Missing’ and ‘Screw’.

The wider STV Studios family also includes Big Light Productions, whose credits include the alternative-history science-fiction drama ‘The Man in the High Castle’. That gives the group some additional genre credentials, although no specific creative team has been confirmed for its ‘Doctor Who’ proposal.

However, the really intriguing element is the reported partnership with Screen Scotland, which would see production of ‘Doctor Who’ relocated from Wales to Scotland.

The strengths: STV has grown into a substantial production operation, with experience delivering successful dramas for both UK broadcasters and international streaming platforms.

A Scottish production could bring fresh locations, production opportunities and potentially a different visual identity to the series. Scotland certainly has no shortage of landscapes that could double as alien planets.

The concerns: Moving ‘Doctor Who’ out of Wales would be a major decision.

Since the programme’s revival in 2005, Wales has become central to its production identity, developing an established network of crews, facilities and specialist expertise around the series.

More importantly, the BBC’s tender specifically states a preference for production qualifying in Wales. That doesn’t prohibit a Scottish proposal, but it does mean STV would need to make an extremely convincing case for moving.

It would certainly be one way to start a small inter-Celtic diplomatic incident.

4. BBC Studios: The Mystery Contender

Known for: Previous production of ‘Doctor Who’, with group labels responsible for shows including ‘Happy Valley’, ‘Renegade Nell’ and ‘Sherwood’

Finally, there is BBC Studios, although this is where the shortlist becomes a little less straightforward.

BBC Studios previously produced ‘Doctor Who’ through its in-house drama operation before Bad Wolf took over for the Russell T Davies era.

When the tender opened, BBC Studios was expected to have multiple production labels bidding for the contract. However, Deadline now reports that just one remains on the shortlist.

Crucially, we don’t know which label it is.

The BBC Studios group owns companies including Lookout Point, responsible for ‘Happy Valley’ and ‘Renegade Nell’, and House Productions, which makes ‘Sherwood’. Both demonstrate the range of drama available within the BBC Studios family, but neither has been confirmed as the successful shortlisted label.

Deadline also believes BBC Studios’ in-house Drama Productions operation has not made the cut, while Clerkenwell Films, the company behind ‘Baby Reindeer’, is reportedly no longer in contention.

The strengths: BBC Studios already has extensive knowledge of the franchise, along with substantial production, commercial and international distribution experience.

Keeping the programme within the wider BBC group could also be an attractive option, particularly when it comes to managing a valuable long-running franchise.

Depending on which label is involved, there could be an opportunity to combine that institutional experience with a genuinely fresh creative team.

The concerns: The biggest problem is that we currently know almost nothing about the actual proposal.

Without knowing the label, its creative team or its intended approach, it’s difficult to judge whether this would represent a major reinvention or something closer to the programme’s previous production arrangements.

And while BBC Studios has history with ‘Doctor Who’, that doesn’t automatically mean the winning label would bring back the people responsible for making it previously.

Are There Other Companies on the Shortlist?

Yes, potentially.

Deadline understands that around half a dozen production companies have reached this stage, meaning there may be another one or two bidders whose identities have yet to emerge.

The report also identifies several prominent companies which chose not to bid, including A24 UK, Playground, Mammoth Screen, New Pictures, Big Talk Studios, Expectation and Quay Street.

That means these four reported contenders shouldn’t be mistaken for a complete or officially confirmed final shortlist.

What Happens Next?

The shortlisted companies have reportedly already attended a briefing with the BBC about the next stage of the tender process.

The remaining timetable looks something like this:

  • Early December 2026: Shortlisted producers submit their more detailed proposals.
  • Early 2027: The BBC holds interviews with the bidders and begins discussions around distribution arrangements.
  • March 2027: The BBC is expected to select its winning production company.
  • 2028/29: The target window for the next series to reach television.

Whoever wins will then face the considerable task of assembling a creative team, finding a new Doctor, organising production and getting the programme back on screen.

The BBC has already indicated that it is open to moving away from the strict showrunner structure used by Russell T Davies, Steven Moffat and Chris Chibnall. Instead, the new production could have a lead executive producer overseeing a team of individual episode writers.

That opens up several possibilities, particularly for companies whose strengths lie in producing major television dramas rather than having a single writer running everything.

For me, the biggest question isn’t necessarily which company has the most successful dramas on its CV. All four contenders have strong credentials in different areas.

It’s which of them understands that ‘Doctor Who’ needs to be more than another prestige television thriller. It needs the freedom to be weird, funny, scary, adventurous and occasionally completely ridiculous, sometimes all within the same episode.

There is certainly enough police drama experience among these bidders to reopen AC-12 several times over. What we need now is someone who can deliver a convincing alien invasion without making it feel like a six-part investigation into police corruption.

‘Doctor Who‘ is available now on BBC iPlayer. The BBC is targeting the next series for 2028/29, although no exact UK premiere date has been announced.

If I want to keep track of this or any other shows, I can add them via our Never Miss system, and I’ll be notified when it gets a UK premiere date. Visit Never Miss.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.